| Date | Match |
|---|---|
| 16/08/16 | Abbey Hey 0-3 Padiham * |
| 20/08/16 | Hanley Town 3-0 Abbey Hey * |
| 23/08/16 | Nelson 1-2 Abbey Hey * |
| 27/08/16 | Abbey Hey 0-2 Runcorn Town |
| 03/09/16 | Cammell Laird 0-2 Abbey Hey * |
| 19/10/16 | AFC Darwen 1-3 Abbey Hey * |
| 25/10/16 | Abbey Hey 4-0 Cammell Laird * |
| 29/10/16 | Ashton Town 1-3 Abbey Hey * |
| 16/11/16 | Abbey Hey 1-3 FC United * |
| 03/12/16 | Runcorn Linnets 2-2 Abbey Hey * |
| 07/01/17 | Abbey Hey 3-2 AFC Liverpool * |
| 21/01/17 | Abbey Hey 1-2 Ashton Athletic |
| 07/03/17 | Barnoldswick Tn 3-0 Abbey Hey * |
| 14/03/17 | Abbey Hey 1-1 AFC Darwen * |
| 08/04/17 | Abbey Hey 1-1 1874 Northwich |
| 10/04/17 | Barnton 1-1 Abbey Hey |
| 13/04/17 | Ashton Athletic 0-1 Abbey Hey |
| 17/04/17 | Maine Road 2-2 Abbey Hey |
| 19/04/17 | Bootle 2-1 Abbey Hey MoM |
| 22/04/17 | Abbey Hey 0-1 Bootle |
| 24/04/17 | Atherton Colls 1-0 Abbey Hey |
| 29/04/17 | Congleton Town 6-1 Abbey Hey |
* Indicates appearance as a substitute
